Judges Question Religious 'Neutrality' of Trump's Revised Travel Ban

The Trump administration will name almost a dozen federal judges as nominees for key posts Monday as President Donald Trump works to pack the nation's federal courts with more conservative voices. He said the administration is not discriminating against any religion and has no intent to discriminate.

"I don't know where it ends", Niemeyer said in the hearing. The 9th Circuit is scheduled to hear another challenge to the revised travel ban next week.

The crucial next stage in the legal battle over Donald Trump's attempt to ban entry to the United States from several Muslim-majority countries was to begin yesterday. It restricted entry to the USA for people from six countries - Iran, Libya, Somalia, Sudan, Syria and Yemen - for 90 days.

Judge James A. Wynn Jr. questioned whether there has ever been a case where a president made such definitive and specific statements during a campaign and then issued an executive order that appeared to implement those statement without explicitly doing so. That's why it's a virtual certainty that the executive order banning travel to the USA from certain countries will end up before the Supreme Court.

But Judge Robert King, a Democratic appointee, noted that Trump has never retracted previous statements calling for a Muslim ban.

Judge Henry Floyd brought up comments from Trump and White House Press Secretary Sean Spicer and asked: "Is there anything other than willful blindness that would prevent us from getting behind those statements?" The tone of arguments was generally civil; Judge Paul Niemeyer did express frustration with American Civil Liberties Union lawyer Omar Jadwat when the judge felt that Jadwat was avoiding a direct answer to a question.


Assistant Solicitor General Jeff Wall told the 13 appeals court judges that they should look only at the words in the revised executive order, which makes no mention of religion. They concluded the hearing without issuing a ruling, which could takes weeks to finalize.

But other judges pushed back, suggesting that what candidate Trump said he meant to do during the campaign was relevant to what he actually did.

Judge Dennis Shedd asked why "the president, the executive branch, (was) not entitled to some deference" in concluding that a pause in travel from the six nations would reduce the threat of terrorism.

Several judges took it differently.

A U.S. District Court in Maryland agreed with them and put the order on hold on March 15, just a day before it was due to go into effect, triggering an appeal by the Justice Department.

A federal judge in Maryland who blocked the revised travel ban in March cited Trump's comments as evidence that the executive order is a realization of Trump's promised Muslim ban.


After that version was blocked by the courts, the president signed a new order which dropped Iraq from the list of suspended countries, exempted visa holders, and eased the language on Syrian refugees.

To that, one of the Fourth Circuit judges asked: "So the first order on anything is invalid?" "TRUMP STATEMENT ON PREVENTING MUSLIM IMMIGRATION" had disappeared by Monday afternoon.

But this is the same guy, Jadwat, who argued, with straight face, this: Trump's order is also invalid because it's "completed unprecedented". The original order was blocked by the 9th Circuit on February 9, dealing the Trump White House a major legal defeat in its third week on the job.

The other three appeals court nominees include Notre Dame Law School professor Amy Coney Barrett - another Scalia clerk - to the 7th Circuit, former Alabama Solicitor General Kevin Newsom to the 11th Circuit, and John Bush, a lawyer in private practice, to the 6th Circuit.

But Richard Primus, a professor of constitutional law at the University of MI law school, said he thinks the Supreme Court will ultimately hear the case no matter what the appeals courts decide.



Popular
  • Yates: I warned White House that Flynn could be blackmailed

    Mr Flynn was dismissed as defence intelligence chief by the Obama administration before he became became a Trump supporter. The New York Times , USA Today and Politico are among the additional publications covering Yates' testimony.
    China welcomes ASEAN summit declaration on South China Sea

    China welcomes ASEAN summit declaration on South China Sea

    A Philippine delegation is due to travel to China in May to discuss issues related to the South China Sea. Duterte recovered some ground when President Trump called to extend him an invitation to visit the US.
    Spicer: White House 'looking into' libel laws

    Spicer: White House 'looking into' libel laws

    President Donald Trump says he'd be open to meeting with North Korean leader Kim Jong Un , under the right circumstances.
  • Star Wars fans celebrate May 4th

    This was mentioned by author Alan Arnold when he was chronicling the making of 1980 film, " The Empire Strikes Back ". While the mask is its most expensive " Star Wars " memorabilia, the jeweler has made pricier products.

    Real Madrid striker Morata: I owe us after Juventus goal

    I suffered a great deal about that goal, as I'd have preferred to score against any other club than Real Madrid". He eventually moved to Real's La Fabrica and progressed into a first-team player for the club.
    Taco Bell sales jump; plans more fried chicken 'innovation'

    Taco Bell sales jump; plans more fried chicken 'innovation'

    Whittier Trust Co. lowered its stake in Yum! For the quarter, Yum Brands said it earned $280 million, or 77 cents per share. Following the sale, the chief executive officer now directly owns 36,910 shares in the company, valued at $2,516,154.70.
  • Hamas says Ismail Haniyeh chosen as Islamic group's leader

    Hamas says Ismail Haniyeh chosen as Islamic group's leader

    The Israeli government has said the document aimed to deceive the world that Hamas was becoming more moderate. Meanwhile, the military wing became increasingly influential in Gaza .
    Crosby scores twice, Bonino has victor  as Pens beat Caps

    Crosby scores twice, Bonino has victor as Pens beat Caps

    Malkin's deflection was initially waved off for goaltender interference, but the Penguins challenged and the call was overturned. It wasn't until the second that the scoring started, with Sidney Crosby scoring twice and Alex Ovechkin scoring once.
    Czech PM to submit government resignation in 2nd half of May

    Czech PM to submit government resignation in 2nd half of May

    Markets have a tradition of casting aside Czech political shenanigans, assured by the strength of the country's institutions. It's no secret that Czech President Milos Zeman is not a fan of Prime Minister Bohuslav Sobotka.
  • US upbeat after Turkey talks on Syria, Mattis: 'We'll work it out'

    Mattis told AFP that the United States and Turkey will work together as operations continue to retake Daesh's Syria bastion Raqqa. Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan is to visit President Donald Trump in Washington next week.

    Baahubali 2, Box Office Collection - DAY 6: Film's Hindi Version Races Ahead!

    Baahubali - The Conclusion is one movie which has been performing extraordinary well at the box office all over the world. This makes the total Gross Box office collection on the 6 day of Bahubali - The Conclusion of Rs 65 Crores.
    Heap family honors daughter with #HugsFromHollyDay

    Heap family honors daughter with #HugsFromHollyDay

    The family created the site hugsfromholly.com, a campaign in memory of Holly , who would have turned 4 on Wednesday. To celebrate Holly's legacy the family is asking others to wear pink and spread random acts of kindness.

CONNECT